Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts

December 25, 2020

Why is India failing ?

 Indian government's bad performance is attributed to many things. Fundamentalism, the ruling BJP's overwhelming majority in Parliament and therefore no effective opposition, toppling elected state governments, inability to show compassion to the poor, especially during the migrant labour crisis, inability to show leadership when China attacked India and killed Indian soldiers or when neighbouring Nepal redrew the map and finally rounding up the year with unprecedented farmer protests when the Indian parliament quietly passed farm laws that affects farmers without consultation, debate or discussion.

People have been distracted with Covid-19 for most of the year. It doesn't take much to see that federalism has been dying a slow death since BJP took over. But can that explain a failing economy and large scale unemployment, unseen in the last 45 years? Why are many industrialists either fleeing India or disappearing or committing suicide? All previous governments be it the Indian National Congress, the United Front or even the previous BJP government did one thing the current government is failing to do. While crony capitalists did exist then, the Indian government never did one thing - tell the Reserve Bank of India(RBI) what to do. Politicians suggested economic measures but never dictated economic policy. Even if they tried, the RBI could not lend them money. So despite rampant corruption, political cronies never had the kind of power they have now.

This has lead to demonetization, GST and budgets with no figures all in the name of removing corruption!. Meanwhile,Indian banks are forced to lend without collateral, have been made to do so. Getting loans nowadays has never been as easy without collateral as RBI is now under government control. So, is it any surprise that large corporations headed by crony industrialists of the government are trying to buy up India in bits and pieces.

The farmers have a slogan - No farmers, no food. This is true as the GOI hastily tried to pass farm bills in an attempt to corporatise agriculture forcing farmers to sell it to two of their political cronies. Anyone who has been watching the destruction of the farmers for the past three years would have noticed that right from demonetization in 2017, the Indian farmers have been protesting silently by either crushing their own produce or publicly protesting on a massive scale but to no avail. Neither the prime minister nor anyone from the cabinet of ministers have bothered to talk to them. The farmer suicides have only been increasing since 2017. The signs are all there. First it was privatization of water, then vegetables and fruits and now food grains. The farmers are now on the streets. No government should have this kind of power over land, food and water. If i t does after it has swallowed up state power, then we are only heading for a system where government tells us what to eat and how much to eat. Reminds me of Soviet Union where bread and black coffee was free but everything else cost money, even butter and sugar.

If the current Indian government thinks it can have a functioning Stalinist Russia in India with an undeclared emergency, all I can recall is the words of one freedom fighter who I had interviewed, "Your generation will have to fight a second freedom struggle if you want your rights."

August 24, 2007

Left In The Cold

The Indian Left are a hillarious bunch. Not that other Indian parties are any less crazy but the Left takes the cake. They are still stuck in the Cold War Era while the rest of India has managed to move on inspite of the politicians.

Some of their arguments against the 123 Nuke deal goes like this

  • Indian sovereignity is challenged by the 123 deal.
  • US will dominate India in different aspects.
  • By agreeing to the terms despite the Hyde Act, the current government is cheating the Indian people.
  • Once the deal is done, India cannot have its own independent foreign policy
  • By aligning itself closely with the US, India will be perceived as supporting all US acts including the Iraq war.
  • By treating India as a special case, the US has ulterior motives.
  • Why does India need the deal, IAEA or even the Nuclear Suppliers Group(NSG) when one Indian company has landed a contract for Uranium mining in Niger?

The list goes on and on.


Yeah, yeah, says the BJP which actually began negotiations for the deal with the US Govt. and is currently in the opposition party. BJP is agreeing with the Left which makes the communists uneasy.

The UPA coalition forms the current Indian govt. with the support of the Left. The UPA is a bunch of parties which is headed by the Congress is a scared lot but sees backing out as a loss of face. More importantly, many want to stay in power as there are lots of perks that goes with it. The Congress cannot be seen replacing the Prime Minister unless he volunteers to quit. The only man who seems steadfast is the Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Manmohan Singh for all the wrong reasons.

He defends the deal and his reasons go something like this

  • It will bring India energy security.
  • Nuclear energy is the only clean energy source apart from solar energy!
  • This will also stop India's reliance on others for energy security!
  • One doesn't oppose the deal after 24 months and the Left should be serious.

Now that we have seen both sides arguments let us see how far both of them are correct.

1) No deal with another country is free of strings including the US.
2) The Nuke deal is not about civilian energy -- it is about strategical alignment.
3) Civilian Nuclear Energy will not satisfy energy needs of India. It is not only costly but also at maximum can satisfy 6-8% of the total energy needs of India.
4) China has a similar deal with the US.
5) True, Taurian Resources from Bombay ( now Mumbai) has landed a contract in Niger -- a Uranium exploration contract and not a mining one as claimed.
6) India will stay sovereign despite what the Left may think -- especially those who sympathise with China and see any alignment with US as anti-China, especially the CPM.
7) With the current mess US is in, US will be a junior partner to India in South Asia. Japan and Malaysia would be the main partners of India in Asia.
8) The Indian Left should not take its instructions from China, just as any other Indian party or coalition cannot take instructions from the US.
9) India was the only country in the world that passed a resolution in the Indian Paraliament which unanimously condemned the Iraq war. Not even the Arab League, Islamic nations or regional formations like ASEAN did. 10)Sorry Mr. Singh but what about wind energy which is also a clean source of energy and with peninsular India, the coast lines can be used to maximum advantage.


While the Nuke deal will pull India out of desert after the Pokhran tests and enable it
to be back without signing the NPT or CTBT, it also gives US leverage to conduct
joint exercises in the Bay of Bengal and scare the hell out of North Korea and potentially China which has currently encircled India like author Azam Gill warned in his book - Winds of Change.

While it won't ensure energy security as the poor PM thinks, it will also not endanger the sovereignity of India as the Left says it fears.


To trackback as to why the Left suddenly woke up, it all boils down to the gauntlet thrown to the Left by the current PM, an economist and who has personally staked his reputation on the deal, when he gave an interview to the The Telegraph newspaper based in Calcutta ( now Kolkatta) when he said that he stands by the deal, irrespective of what the Communists think.

How dare the Indian PM think and speak on his own? This is against the ideology of
the Left which calls for "Collective Thinking" -- whatever that means.

This got Karat and Bardhan of the CPM and CPI parties respectively very angry.

Btw, the Indian Left is not one single party but 4 actually, the two major ones being Communist Party of India (CPI) and the Communist Party of India( Marxists) or CPM. There used to be one Communist Party which later split due to ideological differences but that is another story. It proves one cannot think collectively.

So, the Left is threatening to divorce the UPA and BJP led NDA is waiting. Only problem is Left dislikes the BJP more than UPA. The Third Front which is the UNPA doesn't have enough seats even if the Left agrees to marry it, they don't enough seats to keep the government going.
Left doesn't wish to be seen as pulling down a duly elected government.

The Indian Left has painted itself into a corner. It has been appraised of developments of the Nuke deal regularly by the PM but it chose to object 24 months late. Not filing for divorce means it will be perceived as impotent and pro-America.

The Indian Left needs to wake up and update itself immediately.

Or it will be Left in the Cold (pun fully intended).


Copyright © 2007 by Deepa Kandaswamy, All rights reserved.